Top 3 Restaurants in Westmoreland County, according to TribLIVE's 2024 Best of the Best
Westmoreland County diners have spoken. In TribLive’s 2024 Best of the Best awards, food lovers across the region cast their votes for their favorite places to eat, and three standout restaurants rose to the top.
From handmade Italian pastas to premium-cut steaks and fine dining on the riverfront, this year’s top winners reflect the county’s wide-ranging tastes and culinary pride. Here are the gold, silver and bronze award winners in the Restaurants category — and why they’ve earned a loyal following.
Gold Winner: Olives & Peppers
A rustic Italian bistro with a modern twist, Olives & Peppers has become a destination for those craving house-made sauces, pillowy gnocchi, and artfully plated entrées in a cozy, upscale setting.
The restaurant, located in the heart of Greensburg, offers a menu inspired by the Sicilian roots of its founders, featuring standout favorites such as the black truffle risotto and the wildly popular “Sunday Gravy” — a rich red sauce slow-cooked with pork, beef, and veal.
In addition to their warm hospitality and stylish decor, Olives & Peppers is known for its creative cocktails and signature desserts, such as pistachio cannoli and limoncello cake. Their Instagram-friendly presentation has earned them plenty of love on social media.
Here’s a behind-the-scenes glimpse inside Olives & Peppers, captured by @steelcitytastebudz, where handcrafted pasta and culinary artistry take center stage.
Silver Winner: Rodney’s Restaurant
Tucked away in Irwin, Rodney’s Restaurant is a hidden gem that has been impressing diners with its polished service, elegant ambiance and a menu that blends steakhouse staples with chef-driven specials.
Whether it’s the pan-seared sea scallops with white truffle butter or the perfectly chargrilled filet mignon, Rodney’s delivers on flavor and presentation. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, offering pairings that elevate the dining experience.
Locals know it’s the place for anniversaries, celebrations and date nights — but also a welcoming spot for a top-tier weekday dinner.
“Rodney’s is where you go when you want it done right,” one reviewer wrote. “They just get it.”
Bronze Winner: Morelands at Waterworks
Greensburg’s own Morelands at Waterworks offers an experience that blends scenic river views with elevated casual fare. With an emphasis on local ingredients and seasonal menus, Morelands has quickly earned praise for dishes such as bourbon-glazed salmon, crab-stuffed mushrooms, and hand-cut steaks.
Its spacious interior and waterfront patio make it a favorite for both lunch meetings and relaxed evening dinners. Craft beer enthusiasts will also appreciate the rotating tap list, which highlights Pennsylvania breweries.
The restaurant’s commitment to community and atmosphere helped secure its place among the top three.
A Taste of Westmoreland
The 2024 Best of the Best winners showcase the culinary diversity of Westmoreland County. These restaurants not only serve memorable meals but also reflect the passion, hospitality and creativity of the region’s food scene.
Whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through, these top picks are worth a reservation.
Visit BestoftheBest.TribLIVE.com for more information on nominations, voting and this year’s winners.
Remove the ads from your TribLIVE reading experience but still support the journalists who create the content with TribLIVE Ad-Free.