Top Stories

McKees Rocks man pleads guilty in 2015 slaying of widower

Paula Reed Ward
By Paula Reed Ward
2 Min Read June 1, 2022 | 4 years Ago
Go Ad-Free today

A McKees Rocks man pleaded guilty Tuesday to killing an 81-year-old widower in Kennedy seven years ago.

Stephen Day, 39, will serve 10 to 60 years in state prison under a plea agreement reached in the case.

He pleaded guilty to third-degree murder, burglary, theft and receiving stolen property before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie. Day also pleaded guilty to four other burglary and theft charges stemming from other incidents.

Police said Day burglarized Thomas Nicholson’s home in Kennedy on Dec. 27, 2014, and then returned to the house on June 15, 2015, when he killed him.

Nicholson was found dead in his bedroom the next day, with his hands and feet bound. He also had chemical burns and ligature marks.

The medical examiner’s office said that congestive heart failure, hypertension and heart disease contributed to Nicholson’s death.

Neighbors said that Nicholson had lived on his own since his wife died several years earlier.

The motive for the attack, prosecutors said, was money to feed Day’s drug addiction.

When he was arrested in connection with Nicholson’s death, Day was already incarcerated for a home invasion two months earlier.

When he was questioned by investigators, Day told several inconsistent stories — first telling detectives he knew about an “old man (who) was beat and tied up” in Kennedy.

Day told investigators that three men he knew had gone to Nicholson’s home to rob him, and when they returned, they got nervous and went back to “clean up.”

But in another interview days later, Day said he was involved in planning the burglary but not the homicide.

He was charged in the homicide three years later.

Share

Tags:

About the Writers

Push Notifications

Get news alerts first, right in your browser.

Enable Notifications

Content you may have missed

Enjoy TribLIVE, Uninterrupted.

Support our journalism and get an ad-free experience on all your devices.

  • TribLIVE AdFree Monthly

    • Unlimited ad-free articles
    • Pay just $4.99 for your first month
  • TribLIVE AdFree Annually BEST VALUE

    • Unlimited ad-free articles
    • Billed annually, $49.99 for the first year
    • Save 50% on your first year
Get Ad-Free Access Now View other subscription options